Vibrations not so good in solid-state batteries

An international team of researchers, including nanoengineers at the University of California (UC) San Diego, has uncovered nanoscale changes inside solid-state batteries that could offer new insights into improving battery performance.

Using computer simulations and X-ray experiments, the researchers were able to ‘see’ in detail why lithium ions move slowly in a solid electrolyte – specifically, at the electrolyte-electrode interface. Their studies revealed that faster vibrations at the interface make it more difficult for lithium ions to move there than in the rest of the material. Their findings, reported in a paper in Nature Materials, could lead to new strategies for enhancing ionic conductivity in solid-state batteries.

With electrolytes made of solid materials, solid-state batteries hold the promise of being safer, as well as longer lasting and more efficient, than traditional lithium-ion batteries with flammable liquid electrolytes. But a major issue with these batteries is that the movement of lithium ions is more restricted, particularly where the electrolyte makes contact with the electrode.

“Our ability to make better solid-state batteries is hindered by the fact that we do not know what exactly is happening at the interface between these two solids,” said Tod Pascal, a professor of nanoengineering and chemical engineering and a member of the Sustainable Power and Energy Center at the UC San Diego Jacobs School of Engineering, and co-senior author of the paper. “This work provides a new microscope for looking at these sorts of interfaces. By seeing what the lithium ions are doing and understanding how they move through the battery, we can start engineering ways to get them back and forth more efficiently.”

For this study, Pascal teamed up with his long-time collaborator Michael Zuerch, a professor of chemistry at UC Berkeley, to develop a technique for directly probing lithium ions at the electrolyte-electrode interface. Over the past three years, the two groups have worked on developing an entirely new spectroscopic approach for probing buried, functional interfaces such as those present in batteries. Pascal’s lab led the theoretical work, while Zuerch’s lab led the experimental work.

The new technique they developed combines two established approaches. The first is X-ray adsorption spectroscopy, which involves hitting a material with X-ray beams to identify its atomic structure. This method is useful for probing the lithium ions deep inside the material, but not at the interface.

So the researchers used a second method, called second harmonic generation, that can identify atoms specifically at an interface. This involves hitting the atoms with two consecutive pulses of high-energy particles – in this case, high-intensity X-ray beams at a specific energy – so that their electrons can reach a highly energized state, called a double-excited state. This excited state does not last very long, with the electrons eventually returning to their ground state and releasing the adsorbed energy, which is subsequently detected as a signal.

The key here is that only certain atoms, such as those at an interface, can undergo this double excitation. As a result, the detected signals from these experiments would necessarily and only provide information about what is happening right at the interface.

The researchers used this technique on a model solid-state battery consisting of two commonly used battery materials: lithium lanthanum titanium oxide as the solid electrolyte and lithium cobalt oxide as the cathode.

To verify that the signals they saw were indeed coming from the interface, the researchers performed a series of computer simulations, based on methods developed in Pascal’s research group. When the researchers compared the experimental and computational data, they found that the signals matched almost exactly.

“The theoretical work enabled us to fill in the blanks and provide clarity on the signals that we were seeing in the experiments,” said Sasawat Jamnuch, a nanoengineering PhD student in Pascal’s research group and co-first author of the paper. “But a bigger advantage of the theory is that we can use it to answer additional questions. For example, why do these signals appear the way they do?”

To this end, Jamnuch and Pascal took the work a step further. They modeled the dynamics of the lithium ions in the solid electrolyte and uncovered something unexpected. They found that high-frequency vibrations were occurring at the electrolyte interface, and that these vibrations were further restricting the movement of lithium ions compared to the vibrations in the rest of the material.

“This is one of the major findings of this study that we were able to extract with the theory,” said Jamnuch. Battery researchers have long suspected that incompatibility between the solid electrolyte and electrode materials was restricting the movement of lithium ions at the interface. Now, Jamnuch, Pascal and their colleagues show that something else is also at play.

“There is actually some intrinsic resistance to ion motion in this material right at the interface,” said Pascal. “The barrier for lithium ions to get through is not just a function of the two solid materials being mechanically incompatible with each other, it’s also a function of the vibrations in the material itself.”

He described the barrier to ion movement as similar to what a ball would experience if it was bouncing inside a room where the walls were also moving.

“Imagine a room with a ball at the back, and the ball is trying to move to the front,” he said. “Now also imagine that the sides of the room are also moving, back and forth, which causes the ball to bounce from side to side. The total energy is conserved, so if the ball is bouncing more from side to side, it has to move less from back to front. In other words, the faster the sides are moving, the more time the ball spends bouncing around, and the longer it takes to make it to the front.

“Similarly, in these solid-state batteries, the path that the lithium ions take to get through the material is impacted by the fact that the material itself is vibrating at a higher frequency at the interface than in the bulk. So even if there was perfect compatibility between the electrolyte and electrode materials, there would still be resistance to lithium diffusion through the interface because of these high-frequency vibrations.”

Thanks to their computational work, the researchers are laying the groundwork for future solid-state battery designs.

“One idea would be to slow down the vibrations at the interface of the solid electrolyte material,” said Jamnuch. “You can do that by doping the interface with heavy elements, for example.”

“Now that we understand more about how lithium ions get through this system, we can rationally engineer new systems that will make it easier for ions to get through,” said Pascal. “We found new knobs to turn, new ways to optimize these systems.”

This story is adapted from material from the University of California, San Diego, with editorial changes made by Materials Today. The views expressed in this article do not necessarily represent those of Elsevier. Link to original source.